How to Discuss a Book Intelligently (Even If You Didn't Love It) | Chapterly Blog
How to Discuss a Book Intelligently (Even If You Didn't Love It) Quick Answer: To discuss a book intelligently, focus on specific passages rather than vague impressions, ask open-ended questions, and be honest about what did not work for you — disagreement makes for richer conversation than polite agreement. You do not need to have loved a book to say something insightful about it. Finishing a book is one thing. Discussing it intelligently is another. Whether you are in a book club, a college seminar, a work meeting about a shared reading, or just talking with a friend, the ability to articulate your thoughts about a book is a skill worth developing. And here is the uncomfortable truth: you need this skill most for books you did not love. It is easy to gush about a book you adored. It is much harder, and much more valuable, to discuss a book that confused, bored, or frustrated you without simply saying "I didn't like it." Preparing for Discussion Take Notes While Reading The best book discussions start during reading, not after. As you read, mark passages that strike you, whether positively or negatively. Write brief reactions in the margins. Note questions...